I didn't get in to toys until I was in my late 20s, and I'm still kinda sad that it took me so long to find them.
It's gotten to the point where it's just about impossible to hide my collection from my housemates now! lol
Especially since I masturbate at least once every day, so I NEED them to be accessible. I have a full bag of them at the side of my bed right now. I'm sure other people's collection surpass mine by miles, but this is what I have. I'm leaving out anything that never gets used anymore.
"OK" stuff that I used to use a lot, but not that often now:
Finger Vibe. Straps to your finger and allows you to put intense vibration on specific spots.
Medium size bullet vibe with a ribbed silicon sheath.
Rude Boy prostate vibe. Shaped like a "C", curls round the perineum and presses into the prostate.
6 inch jelly buttplug.
Newer stuff that gets regular attention.
3 anal vibrators - normal cylindrical one with a large, flared head. Hits the prostate really well. Anerous-shaped one that also does very good prostate stuff. Vibrates much harder than the cylindrical one. And a weird shaped thing, almost like a long finger with balls bulging out at the joints. The "finger" is bent, so it also hits the prostate nicely.
Anal beads. I have 4 different sets at different sizes. All still get a lot of use. Orgasms involving the anus and prostate are always my goal.
And of course, my fleshlight. The anal version (obviously!). I think it was called "anal trainer" or something. The box said that if you can last 10 minutes with this, you cal last over 20 with any woman/partner. Well, I like to edge and can go over this fleshlight's 10 minutes, but usually end up getting carried away and not even bothering to try. Fleshlights are great, guys. If you haven't got one, fix that!
Finally, my new favourite.
Thick, 8 inch realistic dildo. This is my go-to at the moment. I'm still at the point where it really needs decent pressure and work to get it in my ass all the way. And then, baring down on it and sliding it in and out ... yes. Just yes. Any sex toy that makes you forget that you even have a cock for minutes at a time HAS to be top of the list!
I've been using the dildo for probably 20 minutes at a time. I'm hoping that this will "train" my ass and I'll be able to upgrade soon. As good as this is, I wanna go bigger.